How such cases look
A commercial or land dispute becomes a criminal case, usually for fraud (Article 159 of the Criminal Code) or embezzlement (Article 160). The owner is detained or put on the wanted list, and the business or property changes hands while the case is pending.
Russian law itself recognises the risk. Article 108(1.1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure restricts pre-trial detention for certain economic offences committed in business activity. When detention is ordered anyway, the reasons given are worth examining.
In foreign courts
In Shmatko v Russian Federation [2018] EWHC 3534 (Admin) the High Court recorded that the district judge had discharged a co-defendant after finding evidence of corporate raiding of his company. Courts look for the sequence of events: the dispute, the change of ownership, the criminal complaint, and who benefited.
What the report addresses
- The timeline of the dispute and of the criminal case, from registry and court records.
- Whether the charge fits the commercial facts.
- Links between the complainant, the investigators and the new owners where records show them.
Questions you can put to the expert
Examples to adapt in the letter of instruction. The final wording is for the instructing lawyer.
- Does the criminal charge match the commercial facts in the file?
- What is the sequence of the dispute, the complaint, the arrest and the change of ownership?
- Who benefited from the criminal proceedings?
- Were the legal limits on detention of entrepreneurs respected?
Documents to send
- Corporate and property registry extracts over time
- Court records of the commercial dispute
- The criminal complaint and charging documents
Documents are sent after the conflict check. Copies in the original language are needed; translations are helpful but not required.
Instructing the expert
Write from your firm’s address with the court, the hearing date and the questions in issue. You will receive terms, a curriculum vitae and an anonymised sample report.