Anatoly FursovCountry expert
Case note · 19 December 2018

Shmatko: extradition to Russia barred for lack of independent prison monitoring

Shmatko v Russian Federation [2018] EWHC 3534 (Admin), High Court of England and Wales.

Russia sought the surrender of Mr Shmatko from the United Kingdom. The Russian Federation gave assurances on the conditions in which he would be held, including an assurance that the regional public oversight commission (ONK) would continue to operate independently.

The court reviewed the evidence on the ONKs, including the restrictions placed on how members are nominated and how they can work (paras 45–48). It held that there was “not merely a real risk but a very strong probability” that Mr Shmatko would be held in the Penza region in conditions involving serious violations of Article 3, and that the absence of effective independent monitoring there increased that probability. Because the prosecuting authorities had failed to disclose a recent regional court decision, the court declined to seek further assurances from them (para 55). The appeal was allowed and Mr Shmatko was discharged (para 58).

The court also observed that there was good reason to reconsider the benefit of the doubt given to Russia as a member of the Council of Europe (para 57). Russia left the Council of Europe in 2022.

Why it matters for expert evidence

The decisive question was factual: who can check that assurances are kept, and whether that body is independent. That is a question for a country expert, and it has to be answered for the specific region and facility.

Instructing the expert

Write from your firm’s address with the court, the hearing date and the questions in issue. You will receive terms, a curriculum vitae and an anonymised sample report.