Anatoly FursovCountry expert
Topics

Political motivation of a prosecution

The charge, its timing, the procedural history and the treatment of people in a comparable position.

The legal question

Courts ask about political motivation under several instruments, and the wording differs.

In asylum cases the question is whether the person is at risk of persecution for reasons of political opinion, actual or imputed (Refugee Convention 1951, Article 1A(2)). In extradition cases under the European Convention on Extradition 1957, Article 3(2) bars surrender where there are substantial grounds for believing that the request was made to prosecute or punish a person on account of political opinion. The same test appears in section 81 of the Extradition Act 2003, which applies in England and Wales.

The decision belongs to the court. A report sets out the facts that the court needs to apply the test.

What the report examines

  • Whether the article charged, and the way the investigators describe the conduct, fit the facts in the file.
  • The timeline: the person’s public activity, the opening of the case, detention in absentia, the wanted notice.
  • Procedural features that depart from ordinary practice: transfer of the case between regions, closed hearings, refusal of access to the file, pressure on relatives or business partners.
  • How people in a comparable position have been prosecuted and sentenced, using court registers and published judgments.
  • Economic charges used against owners of businesses that were taken over. In Shmatko v Russian Federation [2018] EWHC 3534 (Admin) the High Court noted that the district judge had discharged a co-defendant on evidence of corporate raiding of his company.

What the report does not do

It does not assess the credibility of the person’s account, which is for the decision-maker. Evidence that points away from political motivation is set out with the same care as evidence that supports it.

Sources. Convention relating to the Status of Refugees (1951), art. 1A(2); European Convention on Extradition (1957), art. 3(2); Extradition Act 2003, s. 81; Shmatko v Russian Federation [2018] EWHC 3534 (Admin).

Questions you can put to the expert

Examples to adapt in the letter of instruction. The final wording is for the instructing lawyer.

  1. Does the conduct described in the charge correspond to the article applied, and how has that article been applied to comparable conduct?
  2. How does the chronology of the case relate to the applicant’s public activity, business dispute or political involvement?
  3. Are there features of the investigation or trial that depart from ordinary practice, and what is their significance?
  4. How have persons in a comparable position been treated, and what sentences have they received?
  5. What evidence points against political motivation, and how much weight can it bear?

Documents to send

  • The charging decision and the decision to open the case
  • The detention order and the wanted notice
  • Evidence of the applicant’s public activity with dates
  • The refusal letter or the extradition request

Documents are sent after the conflict check. Copies in the original language are needed; translations are helpful but not required.

Instructing the expert

Write from your firm’s address with the court, the hearing date and the questions in issue. You will receive terms, a curriculum vitae and an anonymised sample report.