
How the court weighs expert evidence
The Board of Immigration Appeals has held that an expert’s role is to help the Immigration Judge understand the evidence or decide a fact in issue, and that an opinion is persuasive only where it has a reliable factual basis: Matter of J-G-T-, 28 I&N Dec. 97 (BIA 2020).
Reports are therefore built on dated sources and deal with the evidence that points the other way.
Form
- Form
- A sworn declaration with a CV showing qualifications.
- Language
- English. Documents in another language are filed with certified translations (8 C.F.R. § 1003.33).
- Testimony
- By telephone or video at the individual hearing, if the judge allows it, with cross-examination by the government.
Filing and testimony
The declaration is filed with the respondent’s evidence before the individual hearing, within the deadlines set by the Immigration Judge and the Immigration Court Practice Manual. Foreign-language documents need certified English translations. If the expert testifies, the judge may examine his qualifications before accepting him as an expert, and government counsel may cross-examine.
Common challenges
- The opinion lacks a reliable factual basis (Matter of J-G-T-).
- The expert has not engaged with the State Department country report or other contrary evidence.
- The expert’s qualifications do not cover the specific question.
Instructing the expert
Write from your firm’s address with the court, the hearing date and the questions in issue. You will receive terms, a curriculum vitae and an anonymised sample report.