Anatoly FursovCountry expert
Topics

Detention and treatment after surrender

Where a person is likely to be held before trial, in what conditions, and whether assurances given to the court can be checked.

Where the person will be held

The answer depends on the charge and the region. A person surrendered to Russia is usually held in a pre-trial detention centre (SIZO) of the region where the case is investigated, and may be moved several times before trial.

The report names the likely facility where the information allows it, and sets out what is known about it from inspection reports, court decisions and testimony.

Assurances and monitoring

Courts assess diplomatic assurances against the factors listed by the European Court of Human Rights in Othman (Abu Qatada) v United Kingdom (no. 8139/09, 2012, § 189). One of them is whether compliance can be verified through diplomatic or other monitoring.

English courts have applied this to Russia. The High Court in Dzgoev [2017] EWHC 735 (Admin) said that the Prosecutor General’s Office could not be relied on to verify its own performance and asked for independent verification. In Ioskevich [2018] EWHC 696 (Admin) the assurances were accepted after a jointly instructed expert inspected the detention unit. In Shmatko [2018] EWHC 3534 (Admin) the court found a very strong probability of serious Article 3 violations in the Penza region, increased by the absence of effective independent monitoring, and barred extradition.

What the report addresses

  • The likely place and length of pre-trial detention.
  • Transfers between facilities and access to a lawyer and to family.
  • Treatment of the category of accused: people charged with “extremism”, treason or evasion of mobilisation, and people from the North Caucasus.
  • Who, if anyone, can monitor assurances given to the court after Russia left the Council of Europe.
Sources. Othman (Abu Qatada) v United Kingdom, ECtHR, no. 8139/09, 17 January 2012, § 189; Dzgoev v Prosecutor General’s Office of the Russian Federation [2017] EWHC 735 (Admin); Shmatko v Russian Federation [2018] EWHC 3534 (Admin).

Questions you can put to the expert

Examples to adapt in the letter of instruction. The final wording is for the instructing lawyer.

  1. In which facility is the applicant likely to be held before and after trial?
  2. What is known about conditions, overcrowding, medical care and treatment in that facility?
  3. Who can monitor compliance with assurances, and how independent is that body?
  4. How have comparable assurances been honoured in practice?

Documents to send

  • The extradition request and any assurances
  • Information on the region and the investigating body
  • Medical records if health is relevant

Documents are sent after the conflict check. Copies in the original language are needed; translations are helpful but not required.

Instructing the expert

Write from your firm’s address with the court, the hearing date and the questions in issue. You will receive terms, a curriculum vitae and an anonymised sample report.