Anatoly FursovCountry expert
Royal Courts of Justice, London
Courts

England and Wales

First-tier Tribunal (IAC) · Upper Tribunal · Westminster Magistrates’ Court

Royal Courts of Justice, London

Rules for expert reports

Since 1 November 2024 expert evidence in the First-tier Tribunal is governed by the Tribunal’s Practice Direction.

Length
No more than twenty pages, unless the Tribunal allows more on a reasoned application (para 9.2).
Addressee
The Tribunal, not the party who instructed the expert (para 9.3(a)).
Content
Qualifications; material relied on; the letter of instruction; which facts are within the expert’s own knowledge; the range of opinion with reasons; a summary of conclusions; any qualification to the opinion (para 9.3).
Duty
A statement that the expert understands and has complied with the duty to the Tribunal, and a statement of truth (paras 9.3(k), 9.4).

Expert evidence must be considered before the Tribunal reaches a view on credibility. A tribunal that decides credibility first and then sets the expert report aside makes an error of law: Mibanga v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2005] EWCA Civ 367.

Country guidance

A reported country guidance decision of the Upper Tribunal is treated as authoritative on the issue it decides until it is replaced (para 10). Where one exists, the report explains whether the facts of the case fall within it, or what evidence now justifies departing from it.

Extradition hearings

Under the Extradition Act 2003 the court decides whether the request is made to prosecute the person for political opinions or whether he might be prejudiced at trial for that reason (section 81), and whether extradition is compatible with Convention rights (section 87). Expert evidence is governed by Part 19 of the Criminal Procedure Rules.

Decisions on requests from Russia

Shmatko [2018] EWHC 3534 (Admin)
Extradition barred under Article 3 and the requested person discharged. The court found a very strong probability of serious violations in the Penza region, made greater by the absence of effective independent monitoring. Note
Ioskevich [2018] EWHC 696 (Admin)
Appeal dismissed. The assurances had been verified on site by a jointly instructed expert.
Dzgoev [2017] EWHC 735 (Admin)
The court held that the Prosecutor General’s Office could not verify its own assurances and sought independent verification.
Zakayev, Bow Street, 2003
Extradition refused: the request was politically motivated and there was a real risk of torture.

The outcome depends on the evidence in each case. That is why the report addresses the individual facility and the means of checking assurances.

Sources. First-tier Tribunal (IAC) Practice Direction, 1 November 2024, paras 9, 10; Extradition Act 2003, ss. 81, 87; Criminal Procedure Rules, Part 19; cases as cited.

How the report is used

In asylum appeals the report is filed with the appellant’s evidence in accordance with the Tribunal’s directions, usually well before the hearing so that the Home Office can review it. If the Home Office maintains the refusal, its review should engage with the report. The expert may be directed to give oral evidence, by video where the Tribunal allows.

In extradition proceedings at Westminster Magistrates’ Court, expert evidence is served in accordance with the court’s directions and Part 19 of the Criminal Procedure Rules. The requesting state may instruct its own expert or obtain further information and assurances in response.

Common challenges to expert evidence

  • The expert is not independent of the appellant or his representatives.
  • The report goes beyond the expert’s field or comments on credibility.
  • The report does not engage with the Home Office’s country information or with country guidance.
  • Sources are not identified or dated.
  • The range of opinion is not set out.

Each report is written to meet these points before they are raised.

Checklist for the instructing solicitor

  • The hearing date and any directions on filing evidence
  • The refusal letter and the respondent’s review
  • Relevant CPINs and any country guidance case
  • The questions, in a letter of instruction addressed for the Tribunal’s attention
  • Whether the case is legally aided

Instructing the expert

Write from your firm’s address with the court, the hearing date and the questions in issue. You will receive terms, a curriculum vitae and an anonymised sample report.