Anatoly FursovCountry expert
Case note · 17 March 2005

Mibanga: expert evidence must be weighed before credibility is decided

Mibanga v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2005] EWCA Civ 367, Court of Appeal.

The Court of Appeal held that a fact-finder must not reach a conclusion on credibility before considering all the relevant evidence, including expert evidence. A decision that rejects the appellant’s account first and only then sets the expert evidence aside is wrong in law.

Later decisions of the Upper Tribunal treat the point as one of substance: what matters is whether the judge actually took the expert evidence into account before reaching the credibility finding.

Why it matters for expert evidence

A country report does not decide whether the appellant is telling the truth. It gives the context against which the account is assessed: how prosecutions of this kind are conducted, what documents look like, what happens to relatives. Under Mibanga the tribunal has to engage with that context.

Instructing the expert

Write from your firm’s address with the court, the hearing date and the questions in issue. You will receive terms, a curriculum vitae and an anonymised sample report.