In Dzgoev the High Court applied the factors from Othman v United Kingdom, including whether compliance with assurances can be objectively verified. It said that relying on the Prosecutor General alone to monitor and verify its own performance was an obvious difficulty, and that embassy visits might be enough in some cases but not as the only safeguard (paras 59–61). The court indicated that the appeal would turn on whether adequate independent monitoring was assured (para 68).
In Ioskevich the court accepted the assurances and dismissed the appeal (para 73). As the court in Shmatko later noted (para 51), the assurances in Ioskevich had been verified by Professor Morgan, a jointly instructed expert who visited the detention unit; the court also said that extradition might no longer be ordered if internal monitoring in Russia proved ineffective.
Why it matters for expert evidence
The two cases show that outcomes depend on the evidence about monitoring in the particular case. A report that describes the actual facility, the actual monitoring body and its record gives the court what it needs.
Instructing the expert
Write from your firm’s address with the court, the hearing date and the questions in issue. You will receive terms, a curriculum vitae and an anonymised sample report.