Anatoly FursovCountry expert
Topics

Chechnya and the North Caucasus

Risks specific to people from Chechnya and neighbouring republics, including pressure on relatives.

Why the region is treated separately

Requests concerning people from Chechnya, Ingushetia and Dagestan often rest on terrorism or “illegal armed group” charges dating back to the armed conflicts, or on recent “extremism” charges.

The European Court of Human Rights has found Russia responsible for enforced disappearances and killings in Chechnya in a long line of cases, beginning with Bazorkina v Russia (no. 69481/01, 2006). In 2018 the OSCE Moscow Mechanism report on Chechnya described detention and torture of people perceived as gay and of critics of the republic’s leadership.

In extradition proceedings

In Russian Federation v Zakayev (Bow Street Magistrates’ Court, November 2003) the court refused extradition of a Chechen envoy, finding that the request was made for political reasons and that there was a real risk of torture. Each case still turns on its facts, and a report has to address the individual person, the charge and the likely place of detention.

What the report addresses

  • Whether the charge follows patterns seen in other cases from the region.
  • Pressure on relatives who remain in the republic.
  • Whether the person would be held in the republic or elsewhere, and what that means in practice.
  • Whether the person would be safe in another part of Russia, which is the internal relocation question.
Sources. Bazorkina v Russia, ECtHR, no. 69481/01, 27 July 2006; OSCE Moscow Mechanism, Report on Chechnya (Rapporteur Prof. Wolfgang Benedek), December 2018; Russian Federation v Zakayev, Bow Street Magistrates’ Court, 13 November 2003; EUAA, Country Focus: Russian Federation, December 2025.

Questions you can put to the expert

Examples to adapt in the letter of instruction. The final wording is for the instructing lawyer.

  1. Is the charge consistent with patterns in other cases from the region?
  2. What risk do the applicant’s relatives in the republic face, and could it affect the applicant?
  3. Where would the applicant be held, and could republic officials reach him elsewhere in Russia?
  4. Is internal relocation a reasonable option?

Documents to send

  • Charging and wanted documents
  • Information about relatives in the republic and any contacts with officials
  • Evidence of earlier detentions or threats

Documents are sent after the conflict check. Copies in the original language are needed; translations are helpful but not required.

Instructing the expert

Write from your firm’s address with the court, the hearing date and the questions in issue. You will receive terms, a curriculum vitae and an anonymised sample report.