Anatoly FursovCountry expert
Topics

Mobilisation, desertion and refusal to serve

Liability of men who left the Russian Federation or Ukraine during mobilisation, and how refusal to serve is treated.

Russian Federation

Partial mobilisation was announced by Decree No. 647 of 21 September 2022. Three days later Federal Law No. 365-FZ of 24 September 2022 added aggravated forms of offences against military service committed during mobilisation, martial law or wartime, and created Article 352.1 (voluntary surrender).

The provisions that come up most often are Article 328 (evasion of military or alternative service), Article 337 (unauthorised absence) and Article 338 (desertion) of the Criminal Code. Federal Law No. 127-FZ of 14 April 2023 created a unified electronic register of persons liable for military service and allowed summonses to be served electronically.

Ukraine

Ukraine has been under martial law since 24 February 2022. The law on mobilisation was amended by Law No. 3633-IX of 11 April 2024, in force from 18 May 2024. Evasion of mobilisation is an offence under Article 336 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine; unauthorised absence and desertion fall under Articles 407 and 408.

Refusal to serve in asylum law

Prosecution for evasion is not in itself persecution. In the European Union, Article 9(2)(e) of the Qualification Directive covers prosecution for refusal to perform military service in a conflict where that service would involve war crimes. The Court of Justice explained how to apply it in Shepherd (C-472/13, 26 February 2015).

The report sets out the facts the decision-maker needs: whether the person is likely to be called up, the unit and the area where he would serve, how the authorities treat objectors, and the sentences actually imposed.

Sources. Decree of the President of the Russian Federation No. 647 of 21.09.2022; Federal Laws No. 365-FZ of 24.09.2022 and No. 127-FZ of 14.04.2023; Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, arts. 328, 337, 338, 352.1; Law of Ukraine No. 3633-IX of 11.04.2024; Criminal Code of Ukraine, arts. 336, 407, 408; Directive 2011/95/EU, art. 9(2)(e); CJEU, C-472/13 Shepherd; UK Home Office, CPIN Russia: Military service, version 2.0, August 2026.

Questions you can put to the expert

Examples to adapt in the letter of instruction. The final wording is for the instructing lawyer.

  1. Is the applicant liable to be called up, given his age, category and military specialty?
  2. What criminal or administrative liability does he face for leaving or for not responding to a summons?
  3. How are men in his position treated at the border and after return?
  4. Is alternative service or conscientious objection available in practice?
  5. What is known about the conduct of the units he would be likely to serve in?

Documents to send

  • Military ID or registration documents
  • Any summons, paper or electronic
  • Evidence of the date of departure
  • Messages from the military commissariat or employer

Documents are sent after the conflict check. Copies in the original language are needed; translations are helpful but not required.

Instructing the expert

Write from your firm’s address with the court, the hearing date and the questions in issue. You will receive terms, a curriculum vitae and an anonymised sample report.